Keep it Simply Stupid#Apigee by Julia
Making design unreadable to humans
“K” eep “I”t “S” implies “S” stupid when you are designing your API. While APIs are meant for computer-to-computer interaction, the first client of an API is always a human, and the API contract is the first piece of documentation. Developers are more apt to study your payload design before they dig into your docs. Observation studies suggest that developers spend more than 51% of their time in editor and client as compared to ~18% on reference.
For example, if you skim through the payload below it takes some time to understand because instead of property names it includes an “id”. Even the property name “data” does not suggest anything meaningful aside from just being an artifact of the JSON design. A few extra bytes in the payload can save a lot of early confusion and accelerate adoption of your API. Notice how user-ids appearing on the left of the colon (in the position where other examples of JSON ideally have property names) creates confusion in reading the payload.We think that JSON like this is more difficult to learn. If you want to eliminate any ambiguity in the words you choose to describe the data, keep the payload simple and if any of those labels could be interpreted in more than one way, adjust them to be more clear. Here is a sample response from Airlines endpoint of aviation stack API. Notice how the property names clearly explain the expected result while maintaining a simple JSON structure.
“K” eep “I”t “S” implies “S” stupid when you are designing your API. While APIs are meant for computer-to-computer interaction, the first client of an API is always a human, and the API contract is the first piece of documentation. Developers are more apt to study your payload design before they dig into your docs. Observation studies suggest that developers spend more than 51% of their time in editor and client as compared to ~18% on reference.
For example, if you skim through the payload below it takes some time to understand because instead of property names it includes an “id”. Even the property name “data” does not suggest anything meaningful aside from just being an artifact of the JSON design. A few extra bytes in the payload can save a lot of early confusion and accelerate adoption of your API. Notice how user-ids appearing on the left of the colon (in the position where other examples of JSON ideally have property names) creates confusion in reading the payload.
We think that JSON like this is more difficult to learn. If you want to eliminate any ambiguity in the words you choose to describe the data, keep the payload simple and if any of those labels could be interpreted in more than one way, adjust them to be more clear. Here is a sample response from Airlines endpoint of aviation stack API. Notice how the property names clearly explain the expected result while maintaining a simple JSON structure.
Know when you can break the RESTful rules
Being true to the RESTful basics — such as using the correct HTTP verbs, status codes, and stateless resource-based interfaces — can make your customers' lives easier because they don't need to learn an all new lexicon, but remember that the goal is just to help them get their job done. If you put RESTful design first over user experience, then it doesn’t really serve its purpose.
Your goal should be helping your customers be successful with your data, as quickly and easily as possible. Occasionally, that may mean breaking some "rules" of REST to offer simpler and more elegant interfaces. Just be consistent in your design choices across all of your APIs, and be very clear in your documentation about anything that might be peculiar or nonstandard.
Being true to the RESTful basics — such as using the correct HTTP verbs, status codes, and stateless resource-based interfaces — can make your customers' lives easier because they don't need to learn an all new lexicon, but remember that the goal is just to help them get their job done. If you put RESTful design first over user experience, then it doesn’t really serve its purpose.
Your goal should be helping your customers be successful with your data, as quickly and easily as possible. Occasionally, that may mean breaking some "rules" of REST to offer simpler and more elegant interfaces. Just be consistent in your design choices across all of your APIs, and be very clear in your documentation about anything that might be peculiar or nonstandard.
Conclusion
Beyond these common pitfalls, we have also created a comprehensive guide packaging up our rich experience designing and managing APIs at an incredible scale with Google Cloud's API management product, Apigee.
Apigee — Google Cloud’s native API management platform — helps you build, manage, and secure APIs — for any use case, scale, or environment. Get started with Apigee today or check out our documentation for additional information.
Beyond these common pitfalls, we have also created a comprehensive guide packaging up our rich experience designing and managing APIs at an incredible scale with Google Cloud's API management product, Apigee.
Apigee — Google Cloud’s native API management platform — helps you build, manage, and secure APIs — for any use case, scale, or environment. Get started with Apigee today or check out our documentation for additional information.
Comments
Post a Comment